How JustAnswer Works:
  • Ask an Expert
    Experts are full of valuable knowledge and are ready to help with any question. Credentials confirmed by a Fortune 500 verification firm.
  • Get a Professional Answer
    Via email, text message, or notification as you wait on our site. Ask follow up questions if you need to.
  • 100% Satisfaction Guarantee
    Rate the answer you receive.
Ask sean Your Own Question
sean
sean, Ford Technician
Category: Ford
Satisfied Customers: 3105
Experience:  Ford Master Technician.
31670004
Type Your Ford Question Here...
sean is online now

1.6 litre 115 BHP Mondeo Zetec (2012 model) Versus 2.0 litre

Resolved Question:

1.6 litre 115 BHP Mondeo Zetec (2012 model) Versus 2.0 litre 140 BHP Mondeo Zetec (2012 model)

All other things being equal which one should cost more and why?
Which one is better value for money?
I've read that the 1.6 litre ought to be more economical on fuel. I know that it has lower CO2 emissions so it's cheaper on road tax. It's also significantly cheaper to insure. I also know that it may be a couple of seconds slower getting up to top speed on the motorway (but I'm prepared to sacrafice that). So I'm scratching my head wondering where's the snag...

Is it that maybe the jury is still out on the 2012 1.6 litre engine? Perhaps 2 years is not enough time for flaws to come to the fore? Perhaps the weight of the big Mondeo needs the bigger 2.0 litre engine to carry it?

I'm considering purchasing one or the other - leaning towards the 1.6 but worried that I might find out a couple of years down the road that it lacks the power to carry the vehicle. Can you please explain the technicalities of the relationship between engine size/BHP/torque etc. and how that affects engine performance.

I live in a relatively hilly town - driving will be mixed. Perhaps 50% motorway / 50% stop/start around town. Should the choice between 2.0 litre versus 1.6 litre be obvious?
Submitted: 3 years ago.
Category: Ford
Expert:  sean replied 3 years ago.

Hello, I hope the following is of assistance.

Although the 1.6 is new to the Mondeo the original DV6 engine was fitted in the Focus from 2004, the DV6 in the Mondeo is modified compared to this engine although the same engine is now fitted to both the Focus and Mondeo so it is a proven engine. The Mondeo since 2001 has always had 115 PS diesel engine so the power to weight ratio is no concern. Having driven both cars there is a noticeable difference between the 2 power outputs even when the early 115 PS was the 2.0L DW 10 engine rather than the 1.6 used currently for this power output. The 1.6 is used now instead to lower emissions and therefore improve fuel economy and put the car in a lower tax bracket especially for company cats which make up the majority of Mondeo sales.

Originally the larger the engine capacity the more torque the engine produced but due to advanced technology this has been changed giving the advantage of high engine torque from relatively small engines, the 1.6 DV 6 in Mondeo produces 270Nm of torque at 1750 to 2500 RPM, the 2.0 DW 10 produces 320 Nm in 140PS form (it only produces 300 Nm in it's earlier 115 PS form) the higher the power output and torque the better the acceleration but you get the loss in fuel economy.

Some people want the best performance they can have from a certain model and don't worry about fuel economy or the associated costs, they may also use the car for towing, these would buy the 175 or 200 PS model, other people who are concerned more with fuel economy and associated costs rather than performance plus perhaps only use the car for towing very occasionally would opt for the 115 PS version, the 140 and 163 versions are a middle ground.

This is very much a personal choice as each engine has it's benefits and draw backs but the 115 PS DV 6 is a capable engine and can manage the weight of the Mondeo easily but obviously won't have the performance figures of the larger engines but the fuel economy is better averaging around an extra 10 to 15 MPG compared to a 140 PS.

Most people who have tried the 1.6 have been surprised by it's ability especially it's fuel economy achieving over 60 MPG average if stop/start equipped which is very good for a car of this size.

I hope this helps in your decision making but if I can advise further let me now and I'll reply as soon as I'm able to.

Best wishes,

Sean.

sean and other Ford Specialists are ready to help you