Ask a Law Question, Get an Answer ASAP!
Hello, my name is XXXXX XXXXX it is my pleasure to assist you with your question today.
Why did they give you coal for life, was that a contractual benefit?
Yes it was in the terms when i finished work
Did it say cash alternatives existed?
yes they asked me if I would Chang to gas as an alternative that was a money value.
Unfortunately there would be no legal obligation on your employer to offer you any cash alternative for this. The terms of your contract allowed you to receive coal for life following retirement or termination of employment. The employer is still fulfilling their duty by doing this. If you are no longer able to receive this benefit or simply do not wish to, then the employer does not have to find other alternatives to continue providing this - it is either coal or nothing at all I'm afraid. Had there been an alternative way of receiving this benefit, it would have been detailed in the terms of the contract that dealt with this - in the absence of any such alternatives then the employer is not obliged to offer you anything else than what they are already offering you. You can either continue receiving this as it stands, or you can decide you wish to give up your right to receive it but the employer does not have to offer you an alternative in that case.
They may have asked you to take gas as an alternative but they could not force you to do this and neither could you - this would be something for you to agree between yourselves. Same with getting a money alternative - there is nothing stopping you from asking them top consider this but they do not have to offer it, that would be at their discretion.
Can I still have my coal in Thailand I am going to live ther.
yes but the company would not be responsible for sending it there - they can still provide it for you here but how you get it to Thailand would be up to you
I see you are trying to exit chat - has your original query been answered or do you need me to clarify anything before I close this at my end?
I will get a supplier in Thailand
how that works will have to be agreed with the employer, but they cannot be expected to send the coal overseas I'm afraid
OK thank you for your advice, have a good Christmas
Many thanks and you too - hope you get to resolve this to your satisfaction