Ask a Law Question, Get an Answer ASAP!
Hello my name is ***** ***** I will help you with this.
How did you pay for the implants originally please?
I paid by Debit card
Thank you. What is it you want to achieve, I assume not to pay the £5000?
When you were told £500 how was that communicated please?
Face to face at a meeting. I was given a receipt which I have
And you were told that this was the cost - £500 to do the work?
I was told at the time that if I had the defective implant removed for one of the same kind, it would be free. However, I was told that for £500 I could have both implants replaced with a superior material.
Ok - you need to write to the Hospital and set out your position and what happened.
You can say that they are in breach of Section 13 of the Sale and Supply of Goods and Services Act 1982 by failing to act with all reasonable skill and care
You can also say that you consider the surgeon has been negligent
You need to say you want the work done for the £500 and if they refuse you will go to Court.
If they do refuse then you can issue proceedings.
You would need to complete form N1
The Court would then issue a claim and a copy to be sent to the other side
They would have an opportunity to defend. What you are asking is an order for specific performance - that is they carry out the work for the £500 which you have paid
The Court will list the matter for hearing and decide whether to make an order doing that
If the Court does and they refuse, this can be considered contempt of Court which they can be warned, fined or sent to prison
Can I clarify anything for you about this today please?
I have arranged a face to face meeting with them to discuss this on Friday. I will request them to honour the original agreement. If they fail to do so then I will follow this course of action as outlined by yourself, many thanks.
Great. Can I help with any else today?
After the last meeting with the Manager when I paid the £500, I was waiting for the confirmation for the operation and was told by her that the decision would be ratified by her Superiors. Subsequently, in a later conversation, she informed me that her Superiors would not ratify this and advised me that I had to pay £5000 for the change of both implants or £4000 to remove them, this seems very unfair. Is such a practise allowed?
I don't think it is right. The price quoted was £500 now they want more
This is not right - you were informed it was £500 and that is the price you should pay
This is breach of contract
Does that help?
Yes, that makes sense. I will outline these points on Friday and may get back to you after the outcome if I need further advice. Thanks again and have a good evening.
Thank you. Please remember to put any future questions for Alex W and I can pick them up
Hi Alex W.
I hope you are well. As discussed, we now had a face to face meeting with the Manager of the Private Health Care Provider and we were not happy with the outcome. We have requested at their advise, copies of all Medical records and the terms and conditions signed so we can check thoroughly and refute why they refuse to correct the faulty implants at no extra cost.
Thanks for the reply. We recorded the whole meeting which went on for 14 minutes. The Manager explained that the original terms and conditions signed by myself for the original operation showed that I was allowed one free operation/remedial work but would be charged for further operations. For this reason, her board of Directors refused to finance the necessary operation to replace the faulty implant. My original operation was in March 2012 and my left implant was replaced FOC in February 2013. My right implant then became faulty earlier this year.
We explained that they still had a duty of care to follow through on these implants and it is no fault of mine that both went wrong. She admitted that they no longer use these type of implants. This would agree with our earlier meeting with the Nurse and Surgeon last month when I was told that there had been a lot of problems with these implants and they had been withdrawn. I then asked her why the Nurse and Surgeon agreed to replace both implants with suitable replacements for a total of £500 which I paid. She advised me that this £500 was only a booking fee for the hospital operation which contradicted what I was told. I explained that this was a lie and a breach of contract and that I had witnesses to what was agreed. Her reply is that they do not accept verbal witnesses and you have to stick to what is written. For this reason, I requested copies of all documents so I could see clearly what was agreed and then proceed with my complaint in a formal manner.
Finally, she outlined the complaints procedure which involves 3 stages:- The first one is to examine all documents and make a complaint in writing to her directly. Then my complaint would be directed to her Regional Director (who is the one who already refused to finance the operation) and then finally to another Regional Director who would be more neutral. If we have no satisfactory answer, then we could proceed with court action. The way it was put was a bit intimidating. We therefore left it at that.
It later turned out that she never gave me a signed release document for these documents to be released. This was sent to me on Monday and I duly signed and scanned these over today. She also said to me on the phone this week that she is waiting for an answer from her head office about my situation. However, after the treatment I have had, I do not want to do business with them anymore.
What do you think?
I agree what do you think the outcome could be? I need to have the faulty implant removed on medical grounds but have no confidence with them to get it resolved. I would want to go somewhere else but don't have the money to do so. Would I get compensation from them if I win this claim?
Hi Alex, I hope you are well and thanks for your help so far. I wrote a long letter of complaint as per their procedure clearly showing all the issues I had and how unhappy I was. I also highlighted that they had shown a breach of contract by their actions so far.
Yesterday, I had a response, they agreed not to charge me extra and to proceed with the agreed operation as per what was agreed in late August this year. I am happy with this but am just concerned that due to the original operation being unsuccessful and the problems I have had with them before, whether to proceed with this. What do you think? Is this the best outcome or should I take it further?