Ask a Law Question, Get an Answer ASAP!
Hi Ben, basically; am I going to have to pay this money or is their a chance the judge will say I dont? That and the added fee's they will probably make me pay.
There is a chance that you won't have to pay the money. It is not as simple as the employer claiming for the month's notice you would have been expected to serve. They can only claim for actual losses which they have incurred as a result of you leaving without serving notice. Have they actually lost the £1200 they are claiming? Can they show that they have? Sometimes the employer has not lost anything because they had existing staff which took on your responsibilities for no additional pay. In that case they can't claim that money because they have not lost it. However, if they have had to get someone in to do your job and that cost them more than what they would have paid you, then they could claim the difference. But they cannot just claim your month's salary . As to other costs they may ask you to pay then those won't be that much because this is a small claims court matter and as such each party pays their own legal costs. You could only be asked to pay their claim and hearing fees and that's if you loe. Those won't be much more than a couple of hundred
Okay, basically there was another IT technican, who has been their since the start and was the one to originally give me my tasks. So he could have easily covered my tasks that I did. I dont know about them being able to prove anything. But they're the kind of company that will try and lie about it so I dont know what kind of defence I have because I'm pretty sure I cant prove any of it..
Also, 2 of my friends also left prior to their notice and have exact duplicates of my contract but they haven't even been contacted and have started new jobs else where. Having left for similar reasons to me. Does that help my case at all? Becuase they're going by what it says in my contract, when it says the same thing in theirs but they were not contacted at all to pay anything.
it is their claim so they have to prove that the losses they are claiming have actually been suffered. As to being treated differently to others that does not matter so much - you each have individual contracts, even if identical, and each will have your own liabilities towards the company so in one case the employer may decide to take no action but it does not mean they cannot take action against another employee in similar circumstances
but you can also use constructive dismissal as a result - where you leave because of a breach of contract by the employer and it allows you to leave with immediate effect
that's because the contract is already void due to the employer's breach and as such the notice period within it no longer applies
How would I go about constructive dismissal? As in, what can I say to prove it was. The only thing I can think of was the jobs they had gotten me to do that I dont think I should have had to do. Often bullied into it. In my contract I was employed as an "IT Technician", but worked under the workshop manager; helping orders and customers and even going on my hands and knees to clean out a water feature.
all of that is relevant - you need to argue that the employer has breached the contract in some way that they did not follow its terms. But even if this is not a reason accepted by the court the employer still has to prove their losses as mentioned earlier
Thank you by the way, I will leave you good results; just a few more questions if possible.How will they have to prove I cost them that amount of money if they do come up with proof. I know because I have friends there still that they didn't hire anyone for about 5 months and when they did they got rid of the guy after about a week. And there was 100% another guy there who could do my job.
Will they need to show finance figures, or loss of money due to stock? The company sells Radios, all I did was support the team and their computers. Never anything critical that could stop them from selling anything or making money. There was no online market, it was all done via phone too.Also, how should I present myself in giving information and my defence. I've never been to court so I dont want to lead with a big story because I think the judge would ignore it instead of if I gave short facts?
they need to link you not giving notice to the losses they are claiming - ho they do that I can't say as it varies from one business to another but they will need to provide evidence. Don't worry too much about presentation - this is quite informal, it will likely just be in a room with a judge and the other side, it's not a grand affair. Follow the Judge's lead - they will know you are not represented and have no experience so they will ask you questions to get to the bottom of things
In your experience do I have a good chance with what I've told you, and if I explained to the judge in the same way are they likely to believe me? I'm not a very good out-speaking person so I will most likely be incredibly nervous and miss facts or information that might be important.Are the judges generally fair? I've read stories where they basically dont really listen because you've not got a lawyer and side with the opposition. So I'm pretty nervous about that.
so many factors can influence an outcome that I cannot say what the outcome would be but you d have valid arguments there and remember that it's for the employer to be able to prove their claim as well. But yes they are fair in these situations, they try and keep things informal and to help the parties where needed - this is the small claims court, it is designed for unrepresented parties like you
Okay, thanks very much for your help. I feel a bit better that I could have some chance of winning. Thank's for your time, have a good evening.
you too, best of luck