Yes they have but the other 3 girls will not agree to anything other than drawing straws
Hi Ben and thank you for your reply. The girls are not disputing that an agreement had been reached. What they are saying is that because one of the girls did not see the room, even though she had the opportunity to do so before signing and had photos of it, that the agreement was unfair.
In all the discussions before signature, no one wanted Selena's room. Megs was going to have the small room but if she was not happy with it then Eoufi would agree to take it instead.
On that basis, Selena signed
Does that help us
Sorry to come back to you again. Is it reasonable for Selena to insist that the 3 girls who did not want the room downstairs draw just 3 straws for the rooms upstairs thereby leaving Selena's part of the initial agreement with them intact.
The parents of the other 3 have said that if Selena will not adhere to the 4 straws suggestion, that she should leave the property. That would cause considerable financial loss and of course she would have nowhere to live whilst at university unless she replicates the expenses she has already incurred and find another house. That sounds like bullying to me. What remedy would be open to her to force these costs on the other 3?
I haven't had an answer to my last question. I think something has gone wrong so I will repeat.
Is it reasonable for Selena to insist that the three girls who did not want the downstairs room, simply draw 3 straws for the upstairs room thereby leaving Selena's agreement with them intact?
The 3 girls and their parents have already said that if Selena will not comply with their new demands, that she should leave the house. That sounds like bullying to me. If she were to do so she would incur considerable costs because she would have to replicate the costs she has already incurred when finding a new home. What remedies would be available to her to force the other 3 to meet those costs?