How JustAnswer Works:
  • Ask an Expert
    Experts are full of valuable knowledge and are ready to help with any question. Credentials confirmed by a Fortune 500 verification firm.
  • Get a Professional Answer
    Via email, text message, or notification as you wait on our site. Ask follow up questions if you need to.
  • Go back-and-forth until satisfied
    Rate the answer you receive.
Ask Tim Cooke Your Own Question
Tim Cooke
Tim Cooke,
Category: HVAC
Satisfied Customers: 184
Experience:  Owner at Self-employed
106972271
Type Your HVAC Question Here...
Tim Cooke is online now

We have a Promax HE Store boiler, 8 years old. We get the

This answer was rated:

We have a Promax HE Store boiler, 8 years old. We get the E119 number on the boiler, requiring us to top up the water. We think that we have had this problem ever since the boiler was installed. Recently it is happening much more frequently, every several days.
JA: Are you getting any error codes or blinking lights on your boiler?
Customer: Can we somehow test the boiler to rule out any leak in the bolier? Can we isolate the boiler to see if the pressure drops overnight? Is it possible to test the separate expansion tank? Thanks
JA: How long has this been going on with your boiler? What have you tried so far?
Customer: Many years, but has recently happening much more frequently.
JA: Anything else we should know to help you best?
Customer: It happened last night. The pressure gauge, which I now check regularly, was at nearly 2 bar when I went to bed. This morning it has dropped to 0.5 bar and the boiler had cut out, so there seemed to be a quick loss of pressure.
Customer: replied 11 days ago.
I added some more details to that shown in the question above. Did you see it?
Customer: replied 11 days ago.
OK, all my comments are now shown above.

Hello, I can help you with this.

Firstly, dispel any idea that the leak is within the boiler casing. If it was, you would see water dripping from its lowest point.

You might be on the right track with the expansion vessel, but first please check the pressure relief valve outlet - there should be a 15mm pipe with an open end outside. If you increase the system pressure to 2.0 bar, does this drip at all? If it's raining and making that difficult to judge, then place a balloon or a plastic sandwich bag over the end, held in place with an elastic band, and see if it fills up.

If it isn't dripping, then you have a leak from a pipe or a connection, somewhere else. Ideally you need to find where the water is going, then you can trace where it's coming from.

If none of the above yields an obvious cause, then closely inspect every radiator valve joint, and every vent and every plug, to check for water. Everything should be bone dry.

Customer: replied 11 days ago.
Hi Tim, thanks for your reply. Firstly, a little more information on our system. In addition to the boiler, I have a Potterton Gold Unvented Indirect Cylinder, and two expansion tanks, primary and secondary tanks. Over the years British Gas (maintenance contract) has put, I think 2 lots, of leak sealer into the system. They are reuctant to put more in case it clogs up any small air vents, etc. Do you think this is reasonable or could we try some more?I am struggling with this. We live on the upper floor of a block of flats. I am unable to locate the pressure relief valve outlet pipe. I have located our flue, but cannot see any pipe adjacent to it.The boiler is sitting on a raised platform, I am unable to see under it or around it, and so not sure if there could be any leaks from it, none are apparent. This matter has been going on for several years although has worsened in the last month. We have not had any complaints about a water leak from the flat below.I have checked around the radiators for any leaks or seepage and can find none.Is there any way of doing a check on the boiler and other equipment?Thanks for your help
Customer: replied 11 days ago.
One more thought - The E119 number always seems to appear in the middle of the night, after the heating has been off for a few to several hours. Might this give us a clue?

I don't think the loss of pressure at night isn't really a clue, but I'll bookmark it.

When you say "check on the boiler", I'm really not sure what you mean. If pressure is dropping then water must be coming out, and if it was coming out of the boiler itself then you would see water.

The only thing that might be near the boiler, but it might not, that could let water out is the PRV (pressure relief valve). That's why you need to locate the outlet from the PRV. Trust me - I've been presented with this symptom hundreds of times.

Now a small apology - I ignored the model of your boiler earlier, and I shouldn't have done. So now I realise that the PRV for your boiler is within the casing, also the tundish, so you will have to remove the front panel from the boiler and locate the tundish. Please see the attached diagram and see how far you get.

I'm not abandoning you - don't panic! If you're in Hertfordshire or London then I could help you, otherwise you will need to do this next step as part of the diagnosis, or call a heating engineer to diagnose the problem.

Apologies - that attachment was nonsense. Try this one.

Customer: replied 11 days ago.
Hi Tim,I've located the tundish, there is no indication of a leak. What do you suggest I do now?My boiler is a 170 model, I think slightly different to the 150 which you sent the diagram for.Following topping up with water last night my boiler has been at about 2.5 bar. Mid afternoon I switched off the boiler and the pressure dropped over 1 to 2 hours to below 1 bar. Is this normal? If not, might it help us diagnose any problem?Thanks

OK. That a pity, as it would have been easy.
The 170 model is identical in all ways except power.
It's intriguing that turning off the boiler appears to have an effect.
Let me have a think for an hour and I will get back to you :-)

In the meantime, does the pressure ever go above 2.5 bar?

A quick follow-up...

Were you able to see the tundish during the period after turning off the boiler, when the pressure was dropping?

An idea - if you place a strip of folded kitchen paper across the tundish opening, you won't have to stand there watching it. After increasing the pressure you can go back later and see if the paper is wet.

They probably don't need to see the QC stickers, but I'll send that photo too.

Customer: replied 11 days ago.
The pressure does not go above 2.5 bar. Interestingly, when adding water last night, I got the impression that the watter stopped flowing in after about 10 seconds of the valves being open, as I could not hear the water flowing.I did not check the tundish after turning off the boiler. When you talk of the tundish opening are you referring to the valve at the top of the tundish?Thanks
Customer: replied 11 days ago.
After turning the boiler back on the pressure has risen to just over 2,5 bar.

What was the pressure just before turning on the boiler?

I was using "opening" as a noun, not a verb - there should be a 'window' in the tundish which is where the drip or flow of water would be visible. Vertically above the tundish should be the PRV, which often has a red plastic knob (but sometimes black or blue).

Customer: replied 11 days ago.
About 1 bar.

OK. I'll describe a commonplace problem and you can see which facts fit this theory...

The purpose of the expansion vessel is to absorb increases in pressure. The EV can lose its charge pressure over months and years, and then it does nothing. Equally, it can fail internally, and then it does nothing.

If the EV has lost its pressure, for whatever reason, the system pressure can rise from around 1 bar to around 3 bar when the boiler heats up. This is a problem, because the PRV will often open slightly and let some water out. When the boiler shuts off and the system cools down, the loss of water becomes evident in a lower pressure than at the beginning of this sequence.

So, the clue is in whether or not there is any loss of water, through the tundish, between the boiler starts from cold, then heats up, then cools down again. Since there is more than one tundish, you need to make sure that you're looking at the correct one, or do the paper test on both of them.

I need to go out for about an hour, but I'll check in here when I get back.

Customer: replied 10 days ago.
You say that there is more than one tundish - On the diagram you sent me earlier there is only one tundish shown. On my boiler this is a solid brass cylinder, there is no window in it. Immediately above the tundish I have a black valve marked 'TPR 15'. I note that the pipework around the tundish in my boiler is slightly different to that shown in the diagram.I do not see any opening in the tundish.Thanks

OK hang on - I'll send a photo...

The tundish in this photo has water trickling through it - that's the abnormal condition.

If you could post a photo of the entire area around and below the 'TPR 15' valve, I can see what you're looking at.

Customer: replied 10 days ago.
I note that the pressure is slowly increasing, it is now up to 2.5 (was about 2.2 earlier) and at the junction of the green and red ranges on the gauge.
Customer: replied 10 days ago.
I don't see any tundish such as the one in your photo.

I'm back sooner than I thought. Please could you attach a photo?

Customer: replied 10 days ago.
I'll send photo soon.
Customer: replied 10 days ago.
Photo 1
Customer: replied 10 days ago.
Photo 2

Excellent photos, and they explain everything.

One minute, I just need to check a fact...

If you need to call me, please feel free: 07753 637786.

This isn't your fault, but your Promax has been installed wrongly.
It's not dangerous, as far as I can tell, but it needs inspecting and correcting. It contravenes Part G of the Building Regulations, which is illegal. Whoever installed it should be reported to the HSE, along with whoever has worked on it since.

In terms of fixing your problem, it's my belief that the EV has no pressure. This is easy for a heating engineer to check , and I can guide you through it. If the EV hasn't failed then it can be recharged; if it needs to be replaced I could guide you, but you'd be better of hiring a heating engineer to do it and to correct the problems.

It's also commonplace for the PRV to have to be replaced when it has been opening a lot - they tend to get sediment trapped on the sealing washer and then the washer will never seal again. PRVs are cheap, but again this is something better done by a professional.

In 35 years of working on heating systems, this is the first time I've ever seen an installer do this. I thought I'd seen everything, but this has amazed me.

How old is the flat?

Customer: replied 10 days ago.
This is worrying! Can you please tell me what is seriously wrong with the installation?
Thanks

1. There's no tundish.
2. There isn't a continuous fall in the pipework from the PRV and the T&PV.
3. There might not be any visible indication where the discharge pipe emerges.
4. It's illegal to install any invented vessel unless competent to do it.
5. The manufacturer's warranty is immediately invalidated.

The tundish is actually supplied by Potterton with the boiler, and they still didn't use it. They couldn't possibly have completed the certification, or notified Building Control about it, unless they lied. The whole installation needs inspecting.

If they didn't know what they were doing, they might have made dangerous mistakes in other flats. I can't see anything that makes me say "don't use it", but like I say it needs inspecting.

Customer: replied 10 days ago.
The boiler is about 9 years old, so I wonder if it is now worth doing anything about this?

Regarding the water leak problem, I see you now suspect the expansion tanks. We have had a maintenance contract with British Gas for years, and I will pass this on to them.

Thanks for your advice.

The most urgent thing is to find out where this pipe (see the green arrow) goes.

I'm certain that the CH expansion vessel has lost its pressure. I don't know about the DHW EV, but the whole installation needs checking. If any inspection is done when selling the flat, then this will be revealed at that stage and will be a problem.

If any British Gas engineer has ever taken the cover off and seen what I can see in that photo, they should be sacked.

Since the flat is less than 10 years old, you could make a claim under the NHBC warranty.

Tim Cooke and other HVAC Specialists are ready to help you
Customer: replied 10 days ago.
I take it that this pipe in your diagram is the outlet pipe that we talked of earlier, and which I was unable to find. The flat is over 20 years old, the boiler was replaced 9 years ago.

Ah. 20 years. I drew the wrong conclusion.

Yes - the marked pipe is the discharge pipe, so an outlet. It must be full of water, which is VERY wrong - that's a risk of Legionella bacteria growth right there.

Shall I send you an extract of the relevant part of the installation instructions, so you can read what they should have done?

Customer: replied 10 days ago.
That may be helpful, thanks

I'm having trouble with my PDF generator, so here's the entire manual.
The pages that underpin what I've been saying are: 3, 4, 9, 25, 26, 59.

Please ask if you need anything explained further.